Toronto · Independent Shariah screening · Updated daily
Guide · Researched from published sources · Content-only (no affiliate programs)

Moving to Questrade from a Big Bank: the Canadian Transfer Guide (2026)

Moving your investments from a big-bank brokerage to Questrade is not a sale and a fresh start — it is a direct, institution-to-institution transfer, and done that way your TFSA room, your RRSP tax shelter, and your holdings themselves all carry over intact. Done the wrong way — withdraw and re-contribute — the same move can trigger RRSP withholding tax, burn TFSA room for the rest of the year, and force you to sell holdings you meant to keep. This guide walks through the transfer itself, what it costs, how long it takes, and the halal clean-up to do once your holdings land.

Updated October 2026 · 14-minute read · Reviewed by the Canadian Halal Investor team

Why people move — and when not to

The usual reason for leaving a big-bank brokerage is cost per trade. Questrade charges $0 commission on stock and ETF trades, and no account fee and no inactivity fee on its published fee schedule. Against the big-bank standard online commissions reported from provider pricing pages in September–October 2026 — RBC Direct Investing $9.95, TD Direct Investing $9.99 ($7.00 for active traders), Scotia iTRADE $9.99 ($4.99 for active traders), CIBC Investor's Edge $6.95 — that gap is real for anyone trading regularly. A dozen trades a year at $9.95 is about $120 a year in commissions alone, before any account fees.

But the commission argument is weaker than it was a year ago, and an honest guide has to say so. BMO InvestorLine eliminated commissions on all stock and ETF trades starting September 14, 2026, becoming the first of the Big Five bank brokerages to do so. If you are already at BMO InvestorLine, moving to Questrade does not save you a per-trade commission — your reasons would have to be something else: the platform, US-dollar handling, ETF selection, or a preference for an independent broker. National Bank Direct Brokerage also charges $0 on online stock and ETF trades, with a $100 annual administration fee unless a waiver applies (for example, $20,000 in eligible assets or being 30 or younger), as covered in our Questrade vs National Bank comparison.

Other legitimate reasons to move include consolidating accounts in one place, escaping a bank platform you dislike, getting dual-currency US-dollar accounts without forced conversion, or wanting Questrade's self-directed account lineup (TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, RESP, RRIF and non-registered) under one login. Reasons that are not good on their own: a promotion, a friend's recommendation, or frustration with a single bad trade. Broker pricing changes often — confirm the current fee schedule at both ends before you move, because a fee advantage you move for can disappear after you arrive.

One more check before anything else: are you moving the right account? A transfer moves one account to the same type of account at the new broker — TFSA to TFSA, RRSP to RRSP. It does not convert a TFSA into an RRSP, and it does not move a registered account into a non-registered account. If what you actually want is a different account type, transfer to the same type first, then make an internal transfer at Questrade — do not improvise a shortcut across account types.

Before you start: the pre-move checklist

Most stalled transfers stall for boring, preventable reasons. Questrade's own transfer guidance names the usual culprits: name mismatches, missing signatures, and open orders. Work through this list before you submit anything:

In-kind vs in-cash: the decision that matters most

Every transfer form asks you to choose, holding by holding or for the whole account: in-kind (move the holding itself) or in-cash (sell it at the old broker, move the cash, rebuy at Questrade). This is the single most consequential choice in the whole move, and the default answer for a halal investor is usually in-kind.

In-kind means your shares and ETF units arrive at Questrade as the same shares and ETF units. You stay invested through the move, you pay no spread and no commission to sell and rebuy, and — importantly for a non-registered account — an in-kind move between your own accounts is generally not a sale, so it does not by itself trigger a capital gain. Book cost usually carries over with the holding. The downsides: it is slower (see timelines below), some holdings cannot move in-kind at all, and you cannot trade the holding while the transfer is in progress.

In-cash means the old broker sells everything first. It is faster and simpler, and it is sometimes the only option — for holdings the receiving broker cannot hold, or for proprietary funds that only exist at the old bank. But in a non-registered account, selling is a disposition: capital gains become taxable in the year of the sale, and you are out of the market between the sale and the rebuy, exposed to whatever the market does in between. In a TFSA or RRSP, the tax cost of selling disappears (the shelter absorbs it), so in-cash is much less costly inside registered accounts — but you still face the out-of-market gap and the bid-ask spread on both sides.

For a halal portfolio, in-kind has a second advantage: it preserves the exact holdings you already screened. An in-cash move forces a rebuy decision for every position, which is an opportunity to re-screen — but also an opportunity to drift. If you do go in-cash for some holdings, re-screen each one before rebuying with our screening methodology and the screener roundup, rather than rebuying on autopilot.

One warning Questrade itself publishes: if you sell mutual funds as part of an in-cash transfer, some funds carry a deferred sales charge (DSC) — a penalty for selling early. Ask the outgoing institution about DSCs and any other redemption penalties before you choose in-cash, because Questrade reimburses transfer fees, not penalties.

The transfer, step by step

The direction of a transfer surprises first-timers: you start at the destination, not at the bank you are leaving. Questrade pulls the account; the old bank does not push it. The steps, following Questrade's published transfer process, are:

  1. Open the matching Questrade account. Open the same account type (TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, non-registered, and so on) with the exact same registration. Opening a Questrade account is free, and there is no minimum balance on its published schedule. Our Questrade TFSA walkthrough covers the account-opening flow for a TFSA; the shape is the same for other account types.
  2. Submit the transfer request at Questrade. In Questrade's platform this is the brokerage transfer-in request: you name the relinquishing institution, the account number, and for each holding whether it moves in-kind or in-cash. For an RRSP transfer, this generates Form T2033 (the direct-transfer form) as part of the process.
  3. Questrade sends the request on. Questrade states it generally sends transfer requests out within 1–3 business days of an online request. From there, the timetable is largely in the old institution's hands — which is why timelines vary so much.
  4. Pause trading and wait. Questrade advises pausing all trading activity once a transfer is initiated, and notes that assets may not be available to trade while the transfer is in progress. Do not place orders in the old account during the move; a trade landing mid-transfer is a reliable way to break it.
  5. Verify on arrival, before you trade. Check every position, quantity, cash balance, and book cost against your saved statement. If a book cost is wrong, upload the old statement and ask Questrade to correct it. Dividends that land in the old account after the transfer completes are usually swept over in a residual sweep; if a stray dividend does not arrive, contact Questrade rather than assuming it is lost.

Do not close the old account yourself before the transfer completes, and do not withdraw money from it to "speed things up." A withdrawal from an RRSP triggers withholding tax immediately and counts as taxable income; a withdrawal from a TFSA followed by a re-contribution in the same year can over-contribute you, because withdrawn TFSA room is not restored until January 1 of the following year. The direct-transfer route exists precisely to avoid both traps.

What it costs, and who pays

A transfer has three possible costs, and only one of them is Questrade's:

For comparison, the reverse direction is worth knowing before you ever need it: Questrade charges $150 to transfer an account out to another institution, full or partial, on its published administrative fee schedule. Moving is cheap to enter and $150 to leave — one more reason to be sure about the move before you make it.

Once you are at Questrade, the ongoing cost picture is the $0 stock and ETF commissions above, no account fee, and no inactivity fee. The costs that remain are the ones that catch newcomers: the 1.5% currency conversion charge if you convert Canadian dollars to US dollars (see the currency section below), $9.95 per online journaling request if you use Norbert's gambit, and $9.95 per mutual fund trade if you keep buying bank-style mutual funds at Questrade. See our Questrade review for the full fee picture.

How long it takes, and what stalls it

Questrade's published guidance is that broker-to-broker transfer requests typically take 15–20 business days to complete, with cash-only transfers faster (days) and in-kind transfers taking up to about six weeks depending on the asset type. Treat 15–20 business days as the normal case and six weeks as the slow-but-not-broken case, especially for in-kind transfers involving mutual funds or institutions that still mail transfer cheques.

The common stalls, all preventable, are: a registration name that does not match exactly; an unsettled trade or open order left running; a DRIP still active; a missing signature or a missing extra document for an RESP or locked-in account; and a holding the old institution will only transfer in-cash when you requested in-kind (or vice versa) — in that case Questrade's form only shows the option the outgoing institution supports, so check what was actually offered before you submit. If a transfer passes six weeks with no movement, the productive move is to ask Questrade's transfer team for the status and the specific blocker, not to submit a second request — duplicate requests create duplicate problems.

Plan your cash around the timeline. Do not schedule a transfer to complete the week you need the money, and do not count on trading a transferred holding the day it is supposed to arrive — Questrade notes that holdings become tradeable the following business day after arrival in a self-directed account. If you hold a position you may need to sell quickly, sell it before the transfer starts (inside the old account, with full awareness of any tax consequence in a non-registered account) rather than during it.

The halal clean-up: what to do with what arrives

Moving brokers does not change what you own — and that is exactly the problem for a halal investor moving from a big bank. Bank brokerages sell the full shelf: interest-bearing bonds, GICs, conventional mutual funds, and money-market funds sit alongside stocks and ETFs. Whatever arrives at Questrade needs the same screening it needed at the bank, and the move is the ideal moment to do it, because you are already looking at every holding.

Shariah callout. A brokerage is a neutral rail — halal or not depends on what you hold inside it, not on the logo on the platform. Questrade's self-directed accounts pass as a rail; margin borrowing, interest-bearing products, options speculation, and unscreened holdings do not pass with them. Screen every holding, avoid margin and interest products entirely, and treat any disputed question as a question for a qualified scholar, not a ruling from this site. See Ask a scholar.

US dollars, currency conversion, and Norbert's gambit

Currency is where a bank-to-Questrade move quietly saves or costs real money, and it deserves its own section. Big-bank brokerages typically convert currency on every US trade at their own spread, and many force conversion back to Canadian dollars on settlement. Questrade's self-directed accounts are dual-currency: you can hold US dollars, settle US trades in US dollars, and avoid converting on every trade. But converting Canadian dollars to US dollars at Questrade costs 1.5% on its published schedule — on a $10,000 conversion, that is about $150, which dwarfs a year's worth of saved commissions for a small account.

If you are moving US-listed holdings (for example SPUS or HLAL) in-kind, they arrive as US-listed holdings and you keep the US-dollar exposure without converting anything — one more reason to prefer in-kind for US positions. If you are moving Canadian dollars that you intend to invest in US securities, the cheap conversion route is Norbert's gambit: buy an interlisted security in Canadian dollars, journal it to the US side, and sell it in US dollars. Questrade charges $9.95 per online journaling request for that step, which beats 1.5% on any conversion above roughly $660. Our Norbert's gambit guide walks through the mechanics, including which ETF to use and the settlement timing.

One caution: do not journal or convert inside a registered account without checking the settlement currency settings first. In a TFSA or RRSP, an unintended conversion on settlement can silently convert US dividends or sale proceeds back to Canadian dollars at the 1.5% rate. Set the currency settlement preference deliberately, once, before your first US trade after the move.

After it lands: verify before you trade

When Questrade confirms the transfer is complete, do not trade for ten minutes. Run this verification first:

  1. Positions: every holding present, quantities matching your saved statement, no holding missing and no duplicate.
  2. Cash: cash balances matching what you expected, including any fractional-share sale proceeds and any residual sweep amounts.
  3. Book cost: average cost per holding matching the old statement. If it is wrong, upload the old statement and ask for a correction now — a wrong book cost becomes a wrong capital-gains calculation later, in a non-registered account.
  4. Account type and registration: TFSA room untouched (no contribution recorded), RRSP shelter intact (no withdrawal recorded), FHSA/RESP status as expected. Check the account activity, not just the balance.
  5. Re-screen and re-purify: screen any holding you have not screened recently, set up purification tracking for dividend payers, and re-total zakat. Then — and only then — place your first trade.

Finally, claim the transfer-fee rebate if one applies: submit the old institution's statement showing the transfer-out fee under Questrade's transfer-in terms (up to $150 per account). It is a small amount of paperwork for money that is otherwise simply gone. And keep the old account open until the rebate and any residual sweep have cleared — closing it early can strand a dividend or a fee refund.

When moving is not worth it

Moving is not always the right call, and a guide that only sells the move is not a guide. Do not move if: you are at BMO InvestorLine and your only reason is commissions (now $0 there too); your holdings are mostly GICs or proprietary funds that would have to be sold at a penalty to move; you need to trade a position in the next few weeks and cannot afford it frozen mid-transfer; your account is small enough that a $100–$150 transfer-out fee, even if rebated, plus the hassle, exceeds a year's commission savings; or you are moving to escape a platform annoyance that a settings change or a phone call would fix. Also weigh the alternative: Wealthsimple Trade charges $0 on stock and ETF trades too, and for some investors its simpler platform is the better destination — compare destinations, not just the exit.

The right reason to move is a durable one: lower ongoing costs at your trading pace, a platform and currency setup that fits how you actually invest, and a clean, screened portfolio on the other side. If that is your reason, the transfer itself is straightforward — start at Questrade, choose in-kind for the holdings you want to keep, budget 15–20 business days, and do the halal clean-up on arrival. The move is a weekend of paperwork and a month of waiting; the portfolio you land with is the part that lasts.

FAQ

Do I start a transfer at my old bank or at Questrade?

At Questrade. The receiving broker pulls the account: you open the matching Questrade account, submit Questrade's transfer-in request naming the old institution, and Questrade sends the request on. Starting at the old bank is the most common first-timer mistake.

Will moving my TFSA or RRSP use up contribution room or trigger tax?

No, if it is a direct institution-to-institution transfer to the same account type. A direct transfer is not a withdrawal and not a contribution, so TFSA room is untouched and an RRSP transfer triggers no withholding tax. Never withdraw and re-contribute instead: an RRSP withdrawal triggers withholding tax immediately, and TFSA room withdrawn in a year is not restored until January 1 of the following year.

Should I transfer in-kind or in-cash?

Usually in-kind: your holdings arrive as the same holdings, you stay invested, and in a non-registered account an in-kind move is generally not a sale, so it does not trigger capital gains by itself. Choose in-cash only for holdings that cannot move in-kind, or when you deliberately want to sell — and check for deferred sales charges on mutual funds before you do.

How much does moving to Questrade cost?

Questrade charges $0 to transfer in and covers the old institution's transfer-out fee up to $150 per account under its transfer-in terms. Budget for the old bank's transfer-out fee first — commonly in the $100 to $150 range per account for big-bank direct brokerages — and remember that penalties such as deferred sales charges and GIC early-redemption penalties are not reimbursed.

How long does a transfer to Questrade take?

Questrade says broker-to-broker transfers typically take 15 to 20 business days, with cash-only transfers faster and in-kind transfers taking up to about six weeks. Name mismatches, open orders, unsettled trades, and extra documents for RESPs or locked-in accounts are the usual delays.

What happens to holdings that fail Shariah screening after the move?

They stay failed. Moving brokers does not change what you own, so screen every holding on arrival and sell the ones that fail rather than keeping them because they survived a transfer. Purification cleans the dividends of holdings that passed screening; it never makes a non-compliant holding permissible.

Affiliate disclosure. This page contains no affiliate links, and the site currently earns no affiliate revenue. If we join affiliate programs in the future, this disclosure will be updated and links will be clearly labeled. Commissions never influence our scores or rankings — this review is based on official documentation and public data, and every product is Shariah-screened before review. Nothing on this site is financial advice.